The Legalities of Antiquities

Sneha Sikand on Asia Society’s panel discussion on collecting Ancient Art

New York: The Asia Society recently conducted a panel discussion on collecting antiquities in the 21st century. The panelists consisted of curators, museum experts, university professors, an attorney specializing in art law, and even a former special agent at the department of Homeland Security on cultural property. Why exactly was a talk on Ancient Art getting attention from such a diverse yet connected group of people?

The conversation actually stemmed from the fact that Ancient Art, especially when there is no official record of it can often get stuck in the middle of legal restrictions. What are the implications when importing works from countries like China and India into USA? Has it been stolen from its rightful owner? Does the Museum have the authority to hold an important artefact? And if so, how does it actually make it through custom regulations?

The Future of the Past started as a discussion about the relevance of antiquities in current times but more importantly, it touched upon the importance of cultural property, and an effort to create some semblance of balance between organizations and people who retain these important works, and people who are actually the rightful owners.

Read an article about this discussion.

 

Stargazing – investigating the intersection of feminist and science fictional themes

Sabah Mathur of Saffronart on a new exhibition in London: Stargazing (22 June-19 July 2012)

London: If the fantastical is what you enjoy then this is just the show for you. Stargazing is an exhibition of works by four contemporary Indian female artists – Chitra Ganesh, Mithu Sen, Anita Dube, and Jaishri Abichandani; and an American artist, Nida Abida.

Curated by Jaishri Abichandani herself, the exhibition includes installation, sculpture, drawings, and prints. The artists address issues of gender, race, and power and approach their work with a sensual, subversive, and dark femininity akin to the energy of Kali, the fierce Hindu Goddess associated with empowerment. In Jaishri’s own work, Cyborg as Self, she envisions herself as a male borg drone and alludes to the androgynous iconography of Ardhanarishvara, which highlights the Goddess as the source of divine power.

Jaishri Abichandani, Cyborg as self, 2012

Jaishri Abichandani, Cyborg as self, 2012, Lightbox
Image credit: Rossi & Rossi
http://www.rossirossi.com/contemporary/exh
ibitions/stargazing#slide-cyborg-as-self

With elements of black magic and science fiction, this exhibition reverberates between the mortal and the mythic. Chitra Ganesh, recently awarded a Guggenheim fellowship, exhibits Performing in Paradise, a portrait of the iconic Grace Jones pulsating with raw, visceral energy. Another rather large work is by Mithu Sen, the winner of the 2010 Skoda prize for Indian contemporary art. Her work, You Owe Me, pries into the male psyche, presenting hermaphroditic male bodies pregnant with impossibilities.

Chitra Ganesh, Performing in Paradise, 2012

Chitra Ganesh, Performing in Paradise, 2012, Acrylic, tempera and ink on canvas
Image credits: Rossi & Rossi
http://www.rossirossi.com/contemporary/exhib
itions/stargazing#slide-performing-in-paradise

Mithu Sen, You owe me!, 2009

Mithu Sen, You owe me!,2009, Mixed Media on custom handmade acid free paper
Image credit: Rossi & Rossi
http://www.rossirossi.com/contemporary/exhibitions/star
gazing#slide-you-owe-me

Read more about this exhibition.

South & South East Asia on Guggenheim’s radar

Manjari Sihare on Guggenheim’s UBS MAP Global Art Initiative

New York: The Solomon R. Guggenheim Museum and Foundation recently announced the Guggenheim UBS MAP Global Art Initiative, an ambitious five-year collaboration with UBS Wealth Management to graph contemporary art from around the world. The initiative is an attempt to extend the Guggenheim’s geographic outreach by building relationships among curators, artists, and educators worldwide in a comprehensive program of curatorial residencies, acquisitions and touring exhibitions. Starting from 2012, the project will focus on South and South East Asia in its first phase followed by Latin America in the second and North Africa and the Middle East in the last and final chapter. The Guggenheim will invite one curator from each region to participate in a two-year residency in New York, and work with the museum staff to identify the best of contemporary art from the region. June Yap, an independent curator based in Singapore, has been selected as the Guggenheim UBS MAP Curator, South and Southeast Asia. Yap is known for her curation of the Singapore Pavilion at the 2011 Venice Biennale and holds a background as Deputy Director and Curator of the Institute of Contemporary Arts Singapore, Assistant Director for Visual Arts at the National Arts Council (Singapore), the Singapore Art Museum. The selection was made by an expert panel instituted by the museum, which included Alexandra Munroe (Samsung Senior Curator of Asian Art, Solomon R. Guggenheim Museum, New York) and Kavita Singh (Associate Professor, School of Arts and Aesthetics, Jawaharlal Nehru University, New Delhi).  Works selected by the UBS MAP curators will be included in the museum’s permanent collection and showcased in a traveling exhibit to inaugurate at the Guggenheim, New York, followed by two other destinations, one among which will be in the focus region. Singapore and Hong Kong are being considered as possible destinations for the 1st exhibit.

The initiative highlights two interesting facets of global art politics. It is reflective of the growing attention towards the east in recent years. While more and more western museums are now focusing on the East, mainstream art fairs tell another story. Fairs such as the New York Frieze and the recently concluded Art Basel have been said to be mostly focused on the West.

Image credit: The Art Newspaper: Art Basel Daily Edition, June 12, 2012
http://www.theartnewspaper.com/fairs/Art-Basel/2012/1.pdf

Of the total 2,500 artists showcased at Art Basel, 23% were American and  whooping 60% artists were from European nations. In spite of the hype surrounding Chinese artists, their participation along with their other South Asian counterparts amounted to a mere 4.3% of the total. This discrepancy between the commercial and institutional infrastructures is a point of curiosity. Richard Armstrong, Director of the Guggenheim Museum and Foundation sheds light on this and talks more about the MAP Global Art Initiative in this video.

On another note, it is also interesting that in a global climate of supposed economic recession, UBS Wealth Management, a Swiss global financial services company, has sponsored the initiative. Perhaps, Indian corporations can learn a thing or two from such international counterparts and display broader empathy for art and culture in the region.

Dhaka Art Summit 2012

Sneha Sikand of Saffronart on the latest entrant in the art fair scene

Dhaka: Held at the Bangladesh Shilpakala Academy from 12 to 15 of April this year, the first ever Dhaka Art Summit (DAS) saw the spotlight focused on  Bangladeshi artists, as the newest players in the world of South Asian art. A total of 249 local artists were featured at the summit. Funded by the Samdani Art Foundation (a non-profit art infrastructure development organization) in collaboration with the Bangladesh National Museum, and the Shilpakala Academy, the aim of DAS was to increase public awareness about the art and artists of Bangladesh, which is why the summit only featured artists practicing within the country. With very little gallery representation in the country, the summit offered artists a new  opportunity for international exposure .

Bizarre and Beauty, 2012
Tayeba Begum Lipi

Rajeeb and Nadia Samdani, leading collectors from Bangladesh and co-founders of the DAS wanted the event to create “positive awareness” about the country’s art community. With the great amount of international media coverage and visitors that the summit received, they feel that it carries forward the trend set by the India Art Fair

Country of Rising Sadness
Mohammad Wahiduzzaman

Apart from the exhibit itself, the summit also featured seminars highlighting the growth of South Asian art in the international market, and the role of Bangladeshi art in it. The seminars were conducted by experts from Tate Modern and Rossi & Rossi Gallery among others. At the closing of the DAS the Samdani Artist Development Award was presented to Khaled Hasan for his work Terror beat of Acid and the Samdani Young Talent Award went to Musrat Reazi for her work Moorang.

Read more about the summit.

Damien Hirst at the Tate Modern

Sabah Mathur of Saffronart visits the Damien Hirst retrospective at Tate Modern, London

Damien Hirst poses in front of his work I Am Become Death, Shatterer of Worlds

London: Damien Hirst is quickly becoming an international phenomenon. After a brief taste of his work at the India Art Fair earlier this year, the large-scale retrospective of his work at the Tate presented an interesting opportunity for a more meaningful engagement with his artistic career. The show is a survey of the work of one of Britain’s richest and most prominent artists, who emerged on the art scene as part of the YBA movement of the 1990s. As I wandered through this ambitious exhibition of an artist who has continually been in the media spotlight over the last 20 years, I realised why Hirst’s work has always been described as controversial. While it evokes feelings of delight for some, it provokes, disturbs and disgusts others. Critics have been quick to label his work ‘con art’, but his popularity can be measured by the queues of people in Tate Modern’s Turbine Hall, waiting to see the exhibition.

The show comprises works spanning Hirst’s career, including photography, painting, sculpture and installation. Spread over fourteen rooms, it charts the artist’s work from his undergraduate days through to the Sotheby’s auction of 2008, where 244 new works by Hirst were presented directly by the artist for auction. The first room, containing his early work, is colourful and fun. Hirstian themes that recur throughout the exhibition are introduced: namely, death and mortality, spots, interesting titles, and, via the block sculpture Boxes, the compartmentalising of things. The rooms following this one are filled with Hirst’s archetypal works from the animals preserved in formaldehyde and the Natural History series to the giant spin paintings, the medicine cabinets and his famous spot paintings. Hirst’s tendency to obsessively repeat himself becomes quite obvious and there did not seem to be much point in including so many spot paintings and medicine cabinets in the exhibition.

The theme of life and death underpins the majority of the works included in the show. Hirst’s works are explicitly concerned with the fundamental dilemmas of human existence. Crematorium, a disproportionately large ashtray filled with cigarette butts and ash, can be seen as a reminder of the inevitability of death. What appears to be a lifetime’s accumulation of the remains of smoking can also be seen to double as the cremated remains of the human body.

 

Two other fantastic representations of the life cycle can be seen in A Thousand Years and In and Out of Love. The former is an installation of a glass vitrine in which maggots hatch and develop into flies, which then feed on a severed cow’s head. Many of the flies meet their end on an insect-o-cutor while others survive to continue the cycle. Hirst takes the principle of bringing real objects into the gallery a step further in this work, creating a literal enactment of birth, death and decay. He does it again in the second installation where the themes of life and death as well as beauty and horror are highlighted. In and Out of Love is a recreation from Hirst’s first solo exhibition in 1991 where in one room, with a specifically maintained humid environment, white canvases were embedded with pupae. Butterflies hatched from these and flitted around the room, feeding on sugar water and flowers, mating and laying eggs. In a second room Hirst showed eight brightly coloured canvases with dead butterflies on their surface and also placed tables in the room with ashtrays full of cigarettes on them. As Hirst has said, in this work the building became the vitrine. For some, this confinement of butterflies to one room is a melancholy prospect, while for others it is fascinating to see so many butterflies flutter around and sometimes even sit on them! Some of the butterflies certainly alighted on my shoulder, only to be promptly flicked off by the security guards.

A Thousand Years, 1990
Image credit: http://www.saatchi-gallery.co.uk/aipe/damien_hirst.htm

In and Out of Love (White Paintings and Live Butterflies), 1991
Image credit- http://www.theartnewspaper.com/articles/Hirst’s+butterfly+takes+a+shine+to+Serota/26282

Dead butterflies reappear as a symbol of beauty and the inherent fragility of life in works such as Doorways to the Kingdom of Heaven where they are arranged into complex patterns reminiscent of medieval stained glass church windows. Interestingly, in I Am Become Death, Shatterer of Worlds kaleidoscopic mandala-like forms recall Hindu and Buddhist traditions. The title is taken from the Bhagavad Gita.

Doorways to the Kingdom of Heaven, 2007
Image credit: http://www.theartsdesk.com/visual-arts/damien-hirst-tate-modern

Dead animals are used in many of Hirst’s works. Vitrines are used as devices to impose control on the fragile subject-matter contained within them. The carcasses of animals are preserved as in life, but at the same time are emphatically dead. Hirst also explores the theme of life and death through one of his most famous works For the Love of God. With this skull that is set with 8,601 diamonds, Hirst is trying to celebrate life by saying ‘to hell with death’ and has been quoted saying, “…what better way of saying that than by taking the ultimate symbol of death and covering it in the ultimate symbol of luxury, desire and decadence.”

While walking through the exhibition it very quickly became evident that this was very expensive art. A lot of money must have been paid to set the diamonds in For the Love of God, and to make the vitrine for A Thousand Years. Expense is built into these works and is part of their aesthetic. One of the last rooms stands testament to Hirst’s financial success with its glittering disco-like appearance. The works in this room, featured in the 2008 auction, are studded with gold and diamonds. However, the themes remain the same although now in a more opulent form.

Whether you consider Hirst’s work macabre or whether you are excited by it, there is no denying that it leaves a lasting impact. While some of his works may be getting repetitive, many of them remain engaging. His use of dualities is summed up by the exhibit in the final room. In The Incomplete Truth a dove is suspended in formaldehyde as if in mid flight. The dove represents hope, peace, and the Holy Spirit. Yet the title of the work remains equivocal.

Read more about this exhibition.

Take a video tour of the exhibition http://www.telegraph.co.uk/culture/culturecritics/charlesspencer/9217107/Alas-Ive-now-seen-Damien-Hirst-in-his-true-colours.html

The Physical Impossibility of Death in the Mind of Someone Living, 1991
Collection: Tate London
Image credit: http://www.tate.org.uk/whatson/tate-modern/exhibition/damien-hirst?gclid =CKu45tHS17ACFU4lfAodBEpV0g